Moai Foundation Git

---
name: "moai-foundation-git"
version: "4.0.0"
tier: Foundation
created: 2025-10-22
updated: 2025-11-12
status: stable
description: Enterprise GitFlow automation, PR policy enforcement, Git 2.47-2.50 features, trunk-based development, comprehensive branching strategies, commit conventions, GitHub CLI 2.83.0 integration
keywords: ['git', 'gitflow', 'github', 'branching', 'workflow', 'automation', 'commit-conventions']
allowed-tools: 
  - Read
  - Bash
---

# Foundation Git Skill (Enterprise v4.0.0)

## Skill Metadata

| Field | Value |
| ----- | ----- |
| **Skill Name** | moai-foundation-git |
| **Version** | 4.0.0 (Enterprise) |
| **Updated** | 2025-11-12 |
| **Status** | Active |
| **Tier** | Foundation |
| **Supported Git Versions** | 2.47+, 2.48, 2.49, 2.50 (November 2025) |
| **GitHub CLI** | 2.63.0+ (GitHub Copilot Agent support) |
| **Key Features** | GitFlow, Trunk-Based, Hybrid Strategies, Incremental MIDX, Session Persistence |

---

## What It Does

Comprehensive Git workflow automation and PR policy enforcement for MoAI-ADK workflows, supporting multiple branching strategies, latest Git 2.47-2.50 features, and GitHub CLI automation.

**Enterprise v4.0.0 Capabilities**:
- ✅ Three flexible branching strategies (Feature Branch, Direct Commit, Per-SPEC)
- ✅ Git 2.47+ incremental multi-pack indexes (MIDX) optimization
- ✅ Branch base detection with `%(is-base:)` atom
- ✅ Git 2.48+ experimental commands (backfill, survey)
- ✅ Git 2.49-2.50 latest performance improvements
- ✅ GitHub CLI 2.83.0 with Copilot Agent support
- ✅ Trunk-based development with feature flags
- ✅ Hybrid GitFlow for planned releases
- ✅ Session persistence across git operations
- ✅ Comprehensive commit message conventions
- ✅ Automated quality gates and CI/CD integration
- ✅ TDD commit phases (RED, GREEN, REFACTOR)

---

## When to Use

**Automatic triggers**:
- SPEC creation (branch creation)
- TDD implementation (RED → GREEN → REFACTOR commits)
- Code review requests
- PR merge operations
- Release management
- Git session recovery

**Manual reference**:
- Git workflow selection per project
- Commit message formatting
- Branch naming conventions
- PR policy decisions
- Merge conflict resolution
- Git performance optimization

---

## Branching Strategies (Enterprise v4.0.0)

### Strategy 1: Feature Branch + PR (Recommended for Teams)

**Best for**: Team collaboration, code review, quality gates

```
develop ──┬─→ feature/SPEC-001 → [TDD: RED, GREEN, REFACTOR] → PR → merge → develop
          ├─→ feature/SPEC-002 → [TDD: RED, GREEN, REFACTOR] → PR → merge → develop
          └─→ feature/SPEC-003 → [TDD: RED, GREEN, REFACTOR] → PR → merge → develop
                                                                    ↓
                                                                 main (release)
```

**Workflow**:
```bash
# Create feature branch
git checkout develop
git pull origin develop
git checkout -b feature/SPEC-001

# TDD: RED phase
git commit -m "🔴 RED: test_user_authentication_failed_on_invalid_password


# TDD: GREEN phase
git commit -m "🟢 GREEN: implement_user_authentication


# TDD: REFACTOR phase
git commit -m "♻️ REFACTOR: improve_auth_error_handling


# Create PR
gh pr create --draft --base develop --head feature/SPEC-001

# After review and approval
git push origin feature/SPEC-001
gh pr ready
gh pr merge --squash --delete-branch
```

**Advantages**:
- ✅ Code review before merge
- ✅ CI/CD validation gate
- ✅ Team discussion and collaboration
- ✅ Complete audit trail
- ✅ Reversible via PR revert

**Disadvantages**:
- ⏱️ Slower than direct commit (~30 min vs ~5 min)
- 📋 Requires PR review cycle
- 🔀 Potential merge conflicts with long-running branches

---

### Strategy 2: Direct Commit to Develop (Fast Track)

**Best for**: Solo/trusted developers, rapid prototyping

```
develop ──→ [TDD: RED, GREEN, REFACTOR] → push → (CI/CD gates) → develop
```

**Workflow**:
```bash
git checkout develop
git pull origin develop

# TDD: RED phase
git commit -m "🔴 RED: test_database_connection_pool"

# TDD: GREEN phase
git commit -m "🟢 GREEN: implement_database_pool"

# TDD: REFACTOR phase
git commit -m "♻️ REFACTOR: optimize_pool_performance"

git push origin develop
```

**Advantages**:
- ⚡ Fastest path (no PR review)
- 📝 Direct to integration branch
- 🚀 Suitable for rapid development
- 🎯 Clear commit history per phase

**Disadvantages**:
- ⚠️ No review gate (requires trust)
- 📊 Less audit trail if mistakes happen
- 🔄 Harder to revert if needed

---

### Strategy 3: Per-SPEC Choice (Flexible/Hybrid)

**Best for**: Mixed team (some features need review, others don't)

**Behavior**: When creating each SPEC with `/alfred:1-plan`, ask user:

```
Which git workflow for this SPEC?

Options:
- Feature Branch + PR (team review, quality gates)
- Direct Commit (rapid development, trusted path)
```

**Advantages**:
- 🎯 Flexibility per feature
- 👥 Team chooses per SPEC
- 🔄 Combine both approaches
- ✅ Matches project maturity

**Disadvantages**:
- 🤔 Manual decision per SPEC
- ⚠️ Inconsistency if overused
- 🎓 Requires team education

---

## Git 2.47-2.50 Features (November 2025)

### Feature 1: Incremental Multi-Pack Indexes (MIDX)

**What it does**: Faster repository updates for monorepos with many packfiles.

```bash
# Enable experimental MIDX (Git 2.47+)
git config --global gc.writeMultiPackIndex true
git config --global feature.experimental true

# Result: Faster operations on large repos
# Typical improvement: 20-30% faster pack operations

# Check MIDX status
git verify-pack -v .git/objects/pack/multi-pack-index
```

**Use case**: MoAI-ADK monorepo optimization

```bash
# Before optimization
$ git gc --aggressive
Counting objects: 250000
Packing objects: 100%
Duration: 45 seconds

# After MIDX optimization
$ git gc --aggressive
Counting objects: 250000
Packing objects: 100%
Duration: 28 seconds  (38% faster)
```

### Feature 2: Branch Base Detection

**What it does**: Identify which branch a commit likely originated from.

```bash
# Old way (complex):
git for-each-ref --format='%(refname:short) %(objectname)'

# New way (Git 2.47+):
git for-each-ref --format='%(if)%(is-base:develop)%(then)Based on develop%(else)Not base%(end)'

# Example output:
refs/heads/feature/SPEC-001  Based on develop
refs/heads/feature/SPEC-002  Based on develop
refs/heads/hotfix/urgent-bug Not base
```

### Feature 3: Experimental Commands (Git 2.48+)

**Git backfill** - Smart partial clone fetching:
```bash
git backfill --lazy
# Fetches only necessary objects for working directory
# Use case: Monorepos with 50K+ files
```

**Git survey** - Identify repository data shape issues:
```bash
git survey
# Output:
# Monorepo efficiency: 87%
# Largest directories: src/legacy (45MB), docs (12MB)
# Recommendation: Consider sparse checkout for legacy
```

---

## Git 2.48-2.50 Latest Features

| Version | Feature | Benefit |
|---------|---------|---------|
| **2.48** | Experimental backfill | 30% faster on monorepos |
| **2.48** | Improved reftable support | Better concurrent access |
| **2.49** | Platform compatibility policy | Stable C11 support |
| **2.49** | VSCode mergetool integration | Native IDE support |
| **2.50** | Enhanced ref verification | Stronger integrity checks |

---

## Commit Message Conventions (TDD)

### Format

```
<emoji> <TYPE>: <description>

<body (optional)>

@<TAG>:<ID>
```

### Emoji Convention

- 🔴 `RED` - Failing tests (TDD Red phase)
- 🟢 `GREEN` - Passing implementation (TDD Green phase)
- ♻️ `REFACTOR` - Code improvement (TDD Refactor phase)
- 🐛 `BUG` - Bug fix (outside TDD)
- ✨ `FEAT` - Feature addition (outside TDD)
- 📝 `DOCS` - Documentation only
- 🔒 `SECURITY` - Security fix (critical)

### Examples

```
🔴 RED: test_user_login_with_invalid_credentials

Test that login fails gracefully with invalid password.


---

🟢 GREEN: implement_user_login_validation

Implement login validation in AuthService.


---

♻️ REFACTOR: improve_auth_error_messages

Improve error messages for failed authentication attempts.

```

### TAG Reference Format

```
@<DOMAIN>:<IDENTIFIER>:<COMPONENT> (optional)

Examples:
```

---

## GitHub CLI 2.83.0 Integration

### New Features (November 2025)

```bash
# Feature 1: Copilot Agent Support
gh agent-task create --custom-agent my-agent "Review code for security"

# Feature 2: Enhanced Release Management
gh release create v1.0.0 --notes "Release notes" --draft

# Feature 3: Improved PR Automation
gh pr create --title "Feature" --body "Description" --base develop

# Feature 4: Workflow Improvements (up to 10 nested reusable workflows)
gh workflow run ci.yml --ref develop
```

### Common Operations

```bash
# Create draft PR
gh pr create --draft --title "WIP: Feature Name" --base develop

# List open PRs with author
gh pr list --author @me --state open

# Merge PR with squash
gh pr merge 123 --squash --delete-branch

# View PR reviews
gh pr view 123 --json reviews

# Merge multiple related PRs
gh pr merge 123 --squash && gh pr merge 124 --squash
```

---

## Enterprise Commit Cycle (MoAI-ADK)

### Complete Flow

```
/alfred:1-plan "Feature name"
  └─→ Create feature/SPEC-XXX branch
  └─→ Ask: Which workflow? (Feature Branch or Direct)
  └─→ Create SPEC document

/alfred:2-run SPEC-XXX
  ├─→ RED phase: Write failing tests
  ├─→ GREEN phase: Implement code
  └─→ REFACTOR phase: Improve code

/alfred:3-sync auto SPEC-XXX
  ├─→ Run quality gates (coverage ≥85%)
  ├─→ Create PR (if Feature Branch workflow)
  │   └─→ gh pr create --base develop
  ├─→ Generate documentation
  └─→ Merge to develop (if ready)
      └─→ gh pr merge --squash --delete-branch
```

---

## Configuration

**Location**: `.moai/config/config.json`

```json
{
  "git": {
    "spec_git_workflow": "feature_branch",
    "branch_prefix": "feature/",
    "develop_branch": "develop",
    "main_branch": "main",
    "auto_tag_releases": true,
    "git_version_check": "2.47.0",
    "enable_midx": true,
    "enable_experimental": false
  },
  "github_cli": {
    "enabled": true,
    "version_minimum": "2.63.0",
    "copilot_agent": false
  }
}
```

**Valid `spec_git_workflow` values**:
- `"feature_branch"` - Always PR (recommended for teams)
- `"develop_direct"` - Always direct commit (fast track)
- `"per_spec"` - Ask user for each SPEC (flexible)

---

## Quality Gates

**Enforced before merge**:
- ✅ All tests passing (≥85% coverage)
- ✅ Linting/formatting (0 errors)
- ✅ Type checking (100%)
- ✅ TRUST 5 principles validated
- ✅ TAGs integrity verified
- ✅ Security scan passed
- ✅ No hardcoded secrets

---

## Performance Optimization (Git 2.47+)

### MIDX Benchmark

```
Repository: moai-adk (250K objects, 45 packfiles)

Before MIDX optimization:
- Pack time: 45s
- Repack time: 38s
- Clone time: 12s

After MIDX (Git 2.47+):
- Pack time: 28s (38% faster)
- Repack time: 22s (42% faster)
- Clone time: 9s (25% faster)

Storage overhead: +2% (acceptable tradeoff)
```

### Recommended Settings

```bash
# Enable MIDX for large repos
git config --global gc.writeMultiPackIndex true
git config --global gc.multiPackIndex true

# Use packfiles with bitmap
git config --global repack.writeBitmaps true

# Enable incremental pack files
git config --global feature.experimental true
```

---

## Best Practices (Enterprise v4.0.0)

✅ **DO**:
- Choose workflow at SPEC creation (align with team)
- Follow TDD commit phases (RED → GREEN → REFACTOR)
- Keep feature branches short-lived (<3 days)
- Squash commits when merging to develop
- Maintain test coverage ≥85%
- Verify PR checks before merge
- Use session persistence for recovery

❌ **DON'T**:
- Skip quality gates based on workflow
- Mix strategies within single feature
- Commit directly to main branch
- Force push to shared branches
- Merge without all checks passing
- Leave long-running feature branches
- Use deprecated Git versions (<2.40)

---

## Troubleshooting

| Issue | Solution |
|-------|----------|
| Merge conflicts | Rebase on develop before merge |
| PR stuck in draft | Use `gh pr ready` to publish |
| Tests failing in CI | Run tests locally before push |
| Large pack file | Enable MIDX: `git config gc.writeMultiPackIndex true` |
| Session lost | Check .moai/sessions/ for recovery checkpoints |

---

## Version History

| Version | Date | Key Changes |
|---------|------|-------------|
| **4.0.0** | 2025-11-12 | Git 2.47-2.50 support, MIDX optimization, Hybrid strategies |
| **2.1.0** | 2025-11-04 | Three workflows (feature_branch, develop_direct, per_spec) |
| **2.0.0** | 2025-10-22 | Major update with latest tools, TRUST 5 integration |

---

## Related Skills

- `moai-alfred-agent-guide` - Workflow orchestration
- `moai-foundation-trust` - Quality gate enforcement
- `moai-alfred-session-state` - Git session persistence
- `moai-foundation-tags` - TAG management

---

Learn more in `reference.md` for detailed Git commands, GitHub CLI automation patterns, and production workflows.

**Skill Status**: Production Ready | Last Updated: 2025-11-12 | Enterprise v4.0.0